Harry Potter Fanfiction – Read Over 85,000 Stories!

OK, well, I can't actually AGREE with THIS one, because, well, we don't now if he's TRIED it. The book never said he hadn't or had tried anything, so I can't judge Dumble on this one!

🤗 Katy

Author Response

I suppose we don’t know. But still he seemed pretty happy to have elves in Hogwarts instead of actual wizards or witches

Dumbledore is RELY anoying!!! He's selfish sometimes!! I AGREE with this, and I agree with dew's and Shadow's reviews! 

Harry WOULD have been, something like, like,..,,,..,,..,..like,.,,,.,.,like Harrymort!

Or Voldarry! Yeh, you get what I mean right?

🤗 Katy

Author Response

I get what you mean completely. N.I.E

Yeh, like dew said, he couldn't back off,.,.,.,.,..😅

🤗 Katy

Author Response

Lol

Yes, he should not have let them get detention, especially at NIGHT, AND with HAGRID (no offence Hagrid)

But he can’t CLEAR a forest! Especially one that houses so many creatures that are mostly innocent! That would be cruel, but I agree. He should have at least put a magical fence or something. That would have been safe.

🤗 Katy

Author Response

No. I don’t want him to clear the forest. I just want him to move some of the more dangerous creatures out of the forest fir the student safety. He only tells everybody once a year not to go in there. It was the same with the third floor corridor. Anybody could have been in the hospital wing when he was announcing it. Plus he terrorises students by saying things like that.

Omg! It's like you READ MY MIND!!! 

I always think things like: Dumbledore, are you STUPID, OR WHAT?!?!?!?

Because, rely, I RELY can't picture Dumbledore NOT concius that the stone is in DANGER! That there is VOLDY behind the SNAKE! That, And omg, he NEW that Sirius wasn't rely a bad guy! AND he NEW that it was VOLDY BEHIND THE TWIZARD TORNUMENT! AND that HE WAS LYING TO HARRY! AND THAT HE'S JUST STUPID SOMETIMES?!?!||?"|111WOIN12EOEJNXQWEQWHE

I mean, I think Dumbledore NOWS somethings, but doesn't SAY ANYTHING, because, well,.,,.,,.,.it amuses him! Maybe he thinks it FUNNY! Like it's just a sort of game!


🤗 Katy

Author Response

Maybe I did read your mind.

YES! AND he was SO obsessed with Voldy, but, rely? He's not THE ONLY bad guy in the world!!! I mean, there could have been a guy that could become even worse than Voldy, that COULD have stolen the stone and, let's be onest, the "protection of the stone" wasn't RELY that good, I mean, if Ron, Hermione and Harry could get past them- 
and here comes someone who says: Yes, but what about the mirror??? 
And I say: HE COULD HAVE JUST KIDNAPPED SOMEONE THAT WANTED THE STONE (not to use it) AND TAKE IT FROM HIM! 

omg! I RELY think Dumbledore LIKES pretending he's dumb


🤗 Katy

Author Response

Dumbledore doesn’t pretend he’s Dumb.

No no no.

Old Dumby actually is Dumb.

-N.I.E

I think Dumble new ALL along, I just can't picture Dumbledore NOT nowing!!! I think it jus, well, amused him.

🤗 Katy

Author Response

Ye old Dumby. Stupid old Dumby.

UUU, ok!

I'm gonna go see it! 

🤗 Katy

Author Response

Thank you Katy!!

I agree with dew, dId YoU sEe PoOr DrAcO's FaCe???!!!???!!!

This is the most TRUE reason by far! 

And how dew said: He was a great WIZARD, not a great PERSON.

And tell me ONE person that BELIVS that he didn't awarded Neville (poor Neville, he's always just a tool) 10 points only to let Gryffindor win house cup!! Poor Neville! I mean, isn't this RUDE?? I THINK HE AWARDED HIM 10 POINTS ONLY TO DON'T MAKE THIS SEEM LIKE HE GIVES HARRY, RON AND HERMIONE THE EXACT POINTS LEFT TO WIN THE CUP! 

He could have awarded 50 points to Ron, Hermione, AND Harry, but no, Harry gets 60 POINTS because he had THE HOUSE SPIRIT! 

Dumbledore IS NOT one of my favourite characters, but I must say, I think if Dumbledore 1 (Dumbledore 1 is the FIRST Dumbledore in the films, the Dumbledore of the first and second film) was in ALL the films, I think I would have liked Dumbledore a bit more, because I prefer Dumbledore 1

LET'S SEE POINT 6!


🤗 Katy

Author Response

Yeah I agree with dew_drops too. Draco’s face was devastating. I mean, the second Dumbledore did an ok ish job; I am forgetting that terrible scene in Harry Potter And The Goblet Of Fire. But still, the other Dumbledore looked so much better.

Me: What does this have to do with Dumbledore??

Me: *reads the last line*

Me: aaahaahaahaahaahaahaahaahaa.,,.,,.,., 😅

Me: Well, as I said in a previous review, Dumbledore didn't car much about others, he only cared about Voldy being dead (I think he didn't care much about himself ether!! I mean, letting someone kill him!! RELY! He only want's Voldy dead!)


🤗 Katy

Author Response

Ye Dumby is getting too old for his Dumb job. Ron says he’s on,y in his 150’s give or take a few years but nobody has ever lived that long before. -N.I.E

I have the impression he didn't CARE much about people! (As long as it helped him kill Voldemort, of course!!)

Just think about Severus! JQOI EHQIWHQWUHQIWU! 

🤗 Katy

Author Response

Lol. N.I.E

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

I don't now if I'm HAVE to laugh, but it makes me laugh!!! 🤣🤣🤣

🤗 Katy

Author Response

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 -N.I.E

SO rite! 🤣

Let's see reason 2!!


🤗 Katy

Author Response

Thank you Katy. -N.I.E

Yeh, dew's rite! He could have donne SOMETHING!!! I mean, isn't he a GREAT wizard!?!??!?!

He is selfish! Only thinking about himself!! POOR HARRY! 

🤗 Katy

Author Response

Can't say anything about this one to! (Because I still have to read the book with Grindelwald in it)

🤗 Katy

Author Response

I don't now who Grindelwald is, because I have to read the book first,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.so.,,,..,,.,.,,..,,..,can't say anything about this one! 😅

🤗 Katy

Author Response

All your points are really good, the older I get the less I agree with Dumbles. He may have done some good but he willingly and knowingly sent Harry back to an abusive household and  drafted teenagers into a war twice. 
The order was made up of 21 years in the first war and had no problem letting a 17 yr old think it was his burden to bare alone to defeat the greatest wizard alive. His will was designed to help 3 teenagers (TEENAGERS!) kill Voldemort. I could go on. There wasn’t a single point you made I disagreed with. Also why would he hire Lockhart when he knew he was faking because he’d met the people who really did it? I think he just wanted to have fun ruin some educations. Also I feel bad for the kids who got no newts because he skipped exams newts are the only credentials in the Wizarding world and he took them away from children! 
Anyway if you read this thank you for letting me rant and I hope you’re having an awesome day

Edit: thanks for reading my story

Author Response

I’m so happy you agree with these. Thanks to you my day is awesome!! I am going to shout you out in one of my stories. I am going to read some of yours. Thank you

Also even if he didn’t know for the first 10 years with the Dursleys he knew after. He was visibly malnourished and surprised people liked him. (Also how did no muggle teachers notice Dudley beating him black and blue) 
You’re break down of Dumbledore is great

Author Response

Thank you I’m SO happy you agree

Well, the forbidden forest was a good source of learning, about magical animals. There were not only beasts, but there were also beautiful creatures like unicorns.

Yes, he should not have let them get detention. Especially at night. With hagrid.

But he can’t CLEAR a forest! Especially one that houses so many creatures that are mostly innocent! That would be cruel. It’s not like he needs to grow crops or somethin.

 BUT

I agree. He should have at least put a magical fence or something. That would have been safe.

Author Response

Thank you, although he did say that it is OUT OF BOUNDS to ALL students. And Harry met VOLDERMORT there.

Yes... but actually he (Harry) couldn’t back off. He had to do it. That magical binding contract made sure of that. Otherwise the fake Mad-eye would know it’s futile to get him in the competition!

Author Response

True, true.

Wow. I never thought of these. But yes, you’re right. And Dumbledore also knew how petunia was. She called lily a FREAK for Merlin’s sake! 

You’re right... if Harry wasn’t so selfless, or wasn’t like his mother, he probably would have been more evil than Voldemort. Definitely stronger.

Author Response

I’m so happy you agree! I checked this story to find it had DOUBLE the reviews! And they are good ones!

Ok. This is true. And he didn’t even give a hint of what was happening to Harry!

Author Response

No hint at all I’m so happy you agree.

Yes. I agree with you on this one. I mean, did you see poor Draco’s face? It was SOUL CRUSHING. 

It might have been good for the gryffindors, but that was unfair. And I’m a Gryffindor myself so.. BOO DUMBLEDORE

He was a great WIZARD, not a great PERSON.

Author Response

Thank you I agree

Dumbledore had reasons why he did all these things. No one ever said there was a right or wrong. 

Other times, the things were out of his power and he couldn't change them

Also, what happened to all of your other stories?

Author Response

I don’t know they just got wiped from my account and btw I’m just putting up a point he was my least favourite character and writing this makes me feel better
P.s. I know I know I have a grudge on Dumbledore. (Mostly because he always lets Gryffindor win the house cup fir literally breathing.)

Okay, I agree with the fact that having DETENTION in the Forbidden Forest is bad. The kids could seriously get hurt in there :/ 

-Penelope 

PS, OMG YOU PLAY PIGGY/ROBLOX ME TOO ME TOO ME TOOO

EDIT: 

IKR! I can't stop playing Piggy once I start. If Minitoon doesn't make a Piggy 2, then I will die. :P lol

Author Response

Thank you and piggy is so addictive but there are definitely plans for piggy 2 so no worry’s plus I can’t believe that the Roblox battles are taking place in piggy that’s HUGE!

Reviews (28 found)

JOIN HARRY POTTER FANFICTION