Harry Potter Fanfiction – Read Over 85,000 Stories!

Well, the forbidden forest was a good source of learning, about magical animals. There were not only beasts, but there were also beautiful creatures like unicorns.

Yes, he should not have let them get detention. Especially at night. With hagrid.

But he can’t CLEAR a forest! Especially one that houses so many creatures that are mostly innocent! That would be cruel. It’s not like he needs to grow crops or somethin.

 BUT

I agree. He should have at least put a magical fence or something. That would have been safe.

Author Response

Yes... but actually he (Harry) couldn’t back off. He had to do it. That magical binding contract made sure of that. Otherwise the fake Mad-eye would know it’s futile to get him in the competition!

Author Response

Wow. I never thought of these. But yes, you’re right. And Dumbledore also knew how petunia was. She called lily a FREAK for Merlin’s sake! 

You’re right... if Harry wasn’t so selfless, or wasn’t like his mother, he probably would have been more evil than Voldemort. Definitely stronger.

Author Response

Ok. This is true. And he didn’t even give a hint of what was happening to Harry!

Author Response

Yes. I agree with you on this one. I mean, did you see poor Draco’s face? It was SOUL CRUSHING. 

It might have been good for the gryffindors, but that was unfair. And I’m a Gryffindor myself so.. BOO DUMBLEDORE

He was a great WIZARD, not a great PERSON.

Author Response

Dumbledore had reasons why he did all these things. No one ever said there was a right or wrong. 

Other times, the things were out of his power and he couldn't change them

Also, what happened to all of your other stories?

Author Response

I don’t know they just got wiped from my account and btw I’m just putting up a point he was my least favourite character and writing this makes me feel better
P.s. I know I know I have a grudge on Dumbledore. (Mostly because he always lets Gryffindor win the house cup fir literally breathing.)

Okay, I agree with the fact that having DETENTION in the Forbidden Forest is bad. The kids could seriously get hurt in there :/ 

-Penelope 

PS, OMG YOU PLAY PIGGY/ROBLOX ME TOO ME TOO ME TOOO

EDIT: 

IKR! I can't stop playing Piggy once I start. If Minitoon doesn't make a Piggy 2, then I will die. :P lol

Author Response

Thank you and piggy is so addictive but there are definitely plans for piggy 2 so no worry’s plus I can’t believe that the Roblox battles are taking place in piggy that’s HUGE!

I play piggy as well, it’s so awesome!

Author Response

Yay it is awesome I so agree

I may not agree with you on some of these but I can't judge you since it's your opinion.

Author Response

Ok I know but I think Dumbledore is a dum old door hanging off his hinges I have updated the story to be better though

I agree with you on all of these here!! Dumbledore was one of my least favorite characters in the whole series because of most of these... and why the hell did he go around ignoring Harry... it's his life.. doesn't he have the right to know whats happening around him?

Author Response

Yay ty so much for understanding

Reviews (10 found)

JOIN HARRY POTTER FANFICTION