{reviewid: 2692350, reviewer: 'alex%20ryans'}
| Review #1, by alex ryans | Her... |
1st May 2012:
Anna I will ask you nicely once
please start writing your arse off
now i will ask you meanly
get your lazy arse up and right.:D
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2567683, reviewer: 'Prongs05JP'}
11th August 2011:
Aww, this was nice! Quite sweet, and I really enjoyed it! Haha, you probably won't even get this review, but I've been checking out a whole load of old fics on this site, and this was a really nice one-shot! I particularly enjoyed the fact that Lily was quiet and shy, rather than being loud and short-tempered. It was refreshing!
Where constructive criticism is concerned, the only thing I really picked up on was speech - whilst the dialogue was lovely, a lot of the time after they spoke you'd do something like this: "...presence in here." Ending with a full stop, I mean. I find writing always flows easier if you put a comma, and I think some grammar-watsit rules... but I dunno. XD
All in all though, a fantastic read, thank you for sharing and letting us read it!
9/10
--Nick xx
__
End of an Era Review Extravaganza: House Cup 2011
Forum Name: Prongs05JP
House: Hufflepuff
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2111159, reviewer: 'Brianna'}
4th May 2009:
I like it! Sufficiently fluffy, and a good representation of Jamesie! I feel like you probably could have done a little more variation on the text between the dialogue that was the same...but that's up to you. All in all, bravo! :^D
Report Review |
{reviewid: 2102738, reviewer: 'elly264'}
21st April 2009:
i really like it please continue
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1222008, reviewer: 'poTTer_cris'}
9th December 2006:
oh right.tnx.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1222007, reviewer: 'hogwarts-ice'}
9th December 2006:
to potter_cris:
potter was not yet headboy because he wasn't seventh year yet...so amos diggory was the headboy in this story..got it?
sorry got carried away..i love this story.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1222005, reviewer: 'poTTer_cris'}
9th December 2006:
i thought potter was headboy?? well other than that your story was great .nice..keep it up...( now, i'm being creepy..-crap-)
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1145202, reviewer: 'SadForSirius'}
| Review #8, by SadForSirius | Her... |
24th September 2006:
So sweet. I love how you portray both Lily and James. They're perfectly shy and innocent. Great job. : )
10/10
Report Review |
{reviewid: 1145195, reviewer: 'SadForSirius'}
24th September 2006:
Wonderful! It was brilliant and sweet. I really liked it.
10/10
Report Review |
{reviewid: 805564, reviewer: 'Katy%20Potter_007'}
| Review #10, by Katy Potter_007 | Her... |
10th December 2005:
awwwwww it was just getting good too!! Please write more!!!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 628628, reviewer: 'alpal53'}
4th August 2005:
keep writing!!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 379984, reviewer: 'AppleBz'}
17th February 2005:
NOOO! YOU KILLED IT! Why did you stop writing!?!? You do know it's been like 2 years for you to come up with an idea?!?! ME NEED UPDATES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! If you ever become interesed to see if you have reviews and you see my one here <-- then please pitty me and update!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! PWEESE?!?!?!?
Report Review |
{reviewid: 123181, reviewer: 'Don%20Raphiel'}
| Review #13, by Don Raphiel | Her... |
27th March 2004:
HELLO!
pls tell me u r goin 2 contin, if not i might b forced to, wait 4 it, 2..
read sumthin else,
that wuld b a terrible shame.
bye
Raphiel
Report Review |
{reviewid: 83572, reviewer: 'Moony15'}
3rd December 2003:
i feel the same as hotPotfan! plz update soon.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 67331, reviewer: 'hotPotfan'}
| Review #15, by hotPotfan | Her... |
7th September 2003:
everytime i see this at the top of the list i hope for it to be updated. WHY ISN'T IT?!?!?!?!?
great story! :)
Report Review |
{reviewid: 67262, reviewer: 'KaOtIcAnGeL'}
7th September 2003:
I love the story it's soooooo cute. it would be great if u wrote more but i like it like this i think it would be better
Report Review |
{reviewid: 48972, reviewer: 'liz'}
8th August 2003:
I really like your story
you have to keep writeing
Report Review |
{reviewid: 48379, reviewer: 'Kristina'}
2nd July 2003:
Interesting, to say the least. It was good. Please continue.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 47492, reviewer: 'Rad'}
26th June 2003:
I love it! Keep writing
Report Review |
{reviewid: 45553, reviewer: 'Professor%20McGonagall'}
| Review #20, by Professor McGonagall | Why him? |
11th June 2003:
Very interesting, writing from both perspectives. I hope you continue.
Report Review |
{reviewid: 41294, reviewer: 'sarahriverhill'}
24th April 2003:
I really liked this! Post more soon!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 40958, reviewer: 'BlueStones'}
19th April 2003:
Hey
I luv lily and James fics! They\'re my favorite! I loved how you made it 2 points of views! If you have a chance would you read my story \"Unexpected Darkness?\"
Thanks!
Loved it!
~Jen
Report Review |
{reviewid: 39655, reviewer: 'Nancy'}
2nd April 2003:
Oh pleaaaaaaaaaasssssssssssssse keep writing!
Don\'t stop writing cause i luv it!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 38810, reviewer: 'chickdude'}
25th March 2003:
if u don\'t post the next chap. soon, i\'ll kill myself, and in my will, i\'ll note that u are responsible for it! This is the best chap. i\'ve heard yet! post post post posst post post post post post post post post post post post post!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Report Review |
{reviewid: 38811, reviewer: 'Magnolia'}
25th March 2003:
ARE YOU EVER GOING TO POST ANOTHER CHAPTER?!?!?! COME ON! PLEASE!!! UR KILLING ME HERE!
Report Review |