14 Reviews Found

Review #1, by Hogwarts27 Wandmaker

5th March 2015:
This was another great chapter. I enjoyed the wand making lesson and reading about the tree wood. And then a promising plot starts to unfold as we see what Umbridge is planning. And I enjoyed the part where Harry gets a warning about it later on from Cliodna in the picture.

Ha Ha - I laughed when I read about the Harry toy figure at the joke shop because I almost decided to put the same thing in the joke shop chapter of my own story, but then decided not to. I thought it was interesting that Fred's portrait seemed to know what was happening with Umbridge. Really good story so far! I'm enjoying it when I have time to read.

 Report Review

Review #2, by Hogwarts27 Godfather

3rd March 2015:
Great Chapter! I enjoyed all of it. My favorite part was the dive into the lake for the stones. Merpeople singing the same song as Andromeda was brilliant! And you even showed us the words - that was great! I enjoyed Harry's dream too. I'm guessing the tree will be part of druid magic too. This seems like the start of a very creative plot.

Author's Response: Thank you for leaving nice review!

It took much time for me to write this chapter, so I'm glad you like it. :)

Your great suggestion always let me think I need to reread and rewrite this story, which reminds me of first feeling when I started this story.

 Report Review

Review #3, by Hogwarts27 Apothecary

3rd March 2015:
Hi, I enjoyed this chapter. It was a good read, and thought it was a good start to a new story. I liked the short opening scene about the druid lands. This already promises the reader the story is going to deal with these problems and develop an interesting plot.

I also like the conflict between the houses against Slytherin for how they behaved in the Rowling books. It makes sense that other houses would have hard feelings about that.

Malfoy owning an apothecary is an interesting idea. I think he could be very successful with it, and I think it suits him well.

One suggestion I would make for both of your sequels is to include a little more story summary than just saying they are sequels. Even for a sequel, I think it's good to describe a little of what the general plot will be, so the reader can decide if it's something they might like. :)

Author's Response: Thank you so much for your awesome review! Writers want to keep going, but sometimes we feel uneasy when we can't guess how readers think after their reading. So I really appreciate for your leaving your thoughts.

In my opinion Dumbledore, even now he is dead, he keeps giving influence on teachers and leaders like Kingsley or Harry. And Hermione always sees things in the right direction, supports Harry to carry on.

Speaking of Draco, my plot may be close to your idea in your story, (if you don't think that way, sorry). He also has right to start fresh life.

 Report Review

Review #4, by TreacleTart Apothecary

2nd March 2015:
Hi There,

I'm here with a review from our swap!

What an interesting story. So Draco and Hermione have returned to Hogwarts, but Harry and Ron have skipped school to become Aurors . Better yet they've been given the task of watching Draco.

The personalities that you've created for each character are good. They seem to stay in line with the characters in the books. Ron is especially well-written.

I'm curious to see how the Druids tie into this. I have to admit the opening and then the reference to them in the apothecary made me wonder what would happen.

If I can offer one critique I would suggest taking a look at some of the grammar. I noticed that you tend to leave words like "the", "a", or "an" out quite a bit. Maybe having a beta reader could help you with this.

Otherwise, I really liked this chapter. I think you've created a lot of potential for a suspenseful, interesting story!


Author's Response: Thanks for stopping by,Kaitlin.
Articles sometimes annoys me.
I got a good beta reader, so I'll ask her about grammar little by little.

Thd idea around druidic things I tried to write was not good enough so I have to write more. I'm thinking to add things in detail.

 Report Review

Review #5, by Violet Potter 434 Ginny’s Angst

13th February 2015:
whole story was amazing so keep writing and don't stop or I'll be forced to ask you to get someone else to keep writing your story for you, even if it means I have to(which is not a good idea ,as you'll find out when my first ever chapter comes out by the end of next week hopefully, I sent it today)
I've read all three of your stories and was deeply impressed I have to say this one is my favourite as im Scottish my self and druids are Celtic belief and Celtic is obviously Scottish, Irish, welsh and in the isle of Mann , Cornwall and Brittany as you already know and I have to say it was you and my grandma who is fully Scottish (I'm not I'm Irish (other side of family) and English - I live there)who inspired me too right this new book about Celtic magic and druids
anyway love your story
from Violet potter 434 /me x

Author's Response: Thank you again for your review, Violet. I just only know a little bit of Scottish tradition. I need to learn more, Hogwarts was born in Edinburgh by J.K.Rowling
, obviously, so in my opinion, writers sometimes need to describe things bringing a kind of Scottish essence in the story. I hope you'll enjoy writing your new story. :)

Talking about Celtic, yes, I know a little bit of traditional Celtic songs which influence a lot on my stories, I'm glad you enjoyed this. Thank you!

 Report Review

Review #6, by ginnyharrypotter1 Dumbledore’s Style and A Frosty Christmas

17th July 2014:
when are you going to write next chapter.. please update, i am waiting for the next chapter ages and i have read this story for 4 times until 30th chapter. Cant wait to know what happens next, great story

Author's Response: Thank you for your encouragement, ginnyharrypotter1.

Next chapter is one-shot story,"Hogmanay", if you read this, you'll find what happened next between Harry and Ginny.

Please read my third fanfiction "Harry Potter and Broomstick Makers", so you'll know their love relationship.

I'm struggling to express twists and turns of the story like J.K.Rowling, inserting some crime story and magic mystery.
Thank you for your kind comments, I greatly appreciate your support. :)

 Report Review

Review #7, by jules Draco’s Angst

8th November 2013:
Great job!

Too much dialog, just needs more description. Otherwise, flawless.

Author's Response: You're right, jules. The latter chapters of this story I might have written them in haste, so I must describe more as you say. Thanks!

 Report Review

Review #8, by jules Godfather

8th November 2013:
Hiya! Still really good! Just work on a few things here and there, like spelling and grammar. Sometimes flow can be disturbed.

I really like Harry in this, you write him beautifully. He's perfect!

Author's Response: Thank you again, jules :)
I'll reread this chapter again.
I always try to describe Harry not to lose the essence J.K.Rowling wrote. If it works out right, I'll be really happy.

 Report Review

Review #9, by jules Apothecary

8th November 2013:
Hi! A really good first chapter! If I were to offer some constructive criticism, all I would say is that you use dialogue a lot. Add some description in between dialogue phrases :D

Author's Response: Hi, jules
Thank you for your review! Your advice let me reconsider about describing the story background and the situation, thank you! :)

 Report Review

Review #10, by dtinch Dumbledore’s Style and A Frosty Christmas

24th October 2013:
another great chapter is harry going to use knott later as he just let knott go so in way he owes harry his life or is that the last we hear from knott

Author's Response: Thank you, again for your review, dtinch:),
I really appreciate for that. All of your reviews will make this story go on, thank you for your support, really. I also need to expand my expression, vocabulary, so if I have extra time, I'll come back to rewrite the past chapters.

 Report Review

Review #11, by Druna_Romione Godfather

10th October 2013:
Wow you could be a famous author, i love your story line it is just so good (almost as good as JK Rowling herself and that is saying something)
i cannot find a fault in this chapter its awesome and the best fanfic i have read so far please write lots of other stories so i can goggle over how amazing they are

Author's Response: Druna_Romione,
Thank you for encouraging me to keep on writing. I reread the chapter two and I reckon I found some grammatical errors. I really have to proofread over and over again. I also had an error in the Response I wrote yesterday in the train from my cell phone, I should've added 'been' to the last part of the response to your review. Grammatical advice also is welcomed. I really would like to write and learn the way like native speakers. I always try to write the exciting one, if you feel it, I'm very glad, thank you.

 Report Review

Review #12, by Druna_Romione Apothecary

9th October 2013:
I really like this chapter it is, on the whole really good however there are a few points where i am confused. Is there a particular reason why harry and Ron are trying to protect Draco rather than trying to kill him and why is Malfoy still at school and harry and Ron aren't. Apart from that it is such a good story so far. I especially like that fact that you jump from one world to another

Author's Response: Thank you for your comment, Druna_Romione. Your review let me keep on writing. I described about why Draco are studying at Hogwarts somewhere, but I forgot which chapter. In my story, Dumbledore loved all students of Hogwarts, after his death McGonagall followed his will, Dumledore thought Draco was also a victim of Voldemort, so he thought Hogwarts should give him a chance. On the contrary, the most of the Aurors don't think so , so they are watching including Harry and Ron , who have already trainee Aurors. If you have any questions please write again, thank you.

 Report Review

Review #13, by dtinch Ancient Druidic Curses

1st October 2013:
Please write more on this one and your sequel to this I am waiting thank you.

Author's Response: Thank you, dtinch for your comment. Your review will let me keep working out the next chapter, I'll try, thank you.

 Report Review

Review #14, by RiddleHarry The Storm

23rd March 2013:
Well for the next chpter maybe harry must lost his mind and be in love with dara.. Just my opinion

Author's Response: Thank you for your review, RiddleHarry. Your opinion maybe right or maybe not. I'll add a new next chapter as soon as possible.

 Report Review
If this is your story and you wish to respond to reviews, please login