Report a Review

This service is designed to allow HPFF users to alert the staff about inappropriate reviews.

Review:my_voice_rising says:
Hi there!

I thought you had an interesting start to your story--certainly unique. At first I thought a bean bag was a weird decision, but this is a Marauders-era fic so it's actually really appropriate for a story taking place in the 1970s!

One thing that stuck out to me was your comment about a "usual bad grade" for Lily, which is a bit odd considering that she made excellent marks during her time at Hogwarts. :)

The addition of a choir class was a nice touch. I always thought it was strange that Hogwarts didn't offer any kind of creative outlet for its students. I also liked the bit about Lily forseeing leather jackets and owls being fashionable, and liking Amos before he was popular. I also like her subconscious desire to be what others don't want her to--perhaps this is why she will eventually drift toward James?

The only thing about her personality that really bugged me was her being so down on herself. In the books she's always portrayed as this really magnetic, sweet person--the kind of person who would stand up for Severus against James, for example--but here she's hard on herself as well as others.

However, I think all of your supporting characters have really good characterization. I like Charmaine being nicknamed "the Doctor" and Alice being a hoarder of gossip despite her tiny self. I think you're off to a strong start, especially after polishing Lily's character a bit more. Nice job! :)

Author's Response: Wow, this has a lot of wonderful feedback! I don't even really know what to say... :)

I know what you mean about Lily's personality - I guess that's the reason why I stopped writing this fanfic.

Aaah, I'm so sorry for making you put so much effort in for an abandoned fic, but it's still much appreciated! I'll keep it in mind for my future Marauder fanfics. :)


Your Name:
Reason for this Report:

Examples:
  • The review is offensive.
  • The review is spam or chit-chat (not actually a review).
  • The review was double posted.
  • The review has formatting problems.
Repeat the number: 135
Submit Report: